What to Say in Cold Emails to Get Startups to Join Your Platform
praneetbrar7
Why Cold Emails Work for Startup Directories
Cold emailing might sound like an outdated or intrusive strategy, but in reality, it remains one of the most effective outreach methods—especially when it comes to connecting with early-stage startups. For startup directories, engaging directly with founders soon after their Product Hunt launch can be a game-changer. A well-crafted cold email doesn’t just invite startups to submit; it positions your platform as a value-adding partner during their most pivotal growth phase.
At this crucial moment, founders are hungry for validation, visibility, and backlinks—and a well-placed link in a reputable directory delivers all three. That’s where cold email outreach, especially when automated by smart tools like NurturingMail, becomes a growth multiplier for directory owners, solopreneurs, and indie hackers alike.
What to Say in Cold Emails to Get Startups to Join Your Platform
This is the million-dollar question. The words you choose can either open the door to collaboration or get your email ignored or deleted. The goal isn’t to sell on the first email—it’s to build a human connection and demonstrate value. Here’s how.
1. Start with a Congratulatory Hook
Begin your email by genuinely congratulating the founder on their Product Hunt launch. Make it personal. Mention their product name and a specific detail about it if possible. This not only shows that you’ve done your homework, but it builds rapport from the very first line.
- “Congrats on launching [Product Name] – saw it go live on Product Hunt today!”
- “Really loved the angle you’re taking on [specific pain point]. Huge congrats on launching on PH!”
This approach mirrors the strategy employed by NurturingMail’s personalized cold emails, which automatically include founder and product names for an authentic touch.
2. Establish Immediate Relevance
Right after congratulating the founder, tell them why you’re reaching out—and more importantly, why it makes sense for them. Make it about what they’ll get, not what you want.
- “I run [Directory Name], a curated list of the best new [niche] startups.”
- “We help early-stage tools like yours gain visibility, backlinks, and initial user traction.”
For example, if you run a productivity tools directory like Aura++, targeting PH productivity launches adds contextual value. Founders will immediately see the connection.
3. Include a Soft Call-to-Action
Too many cold emails make the mistake of pushing for a hard sale right away. Instead, invite the founder to check out your platform or suggest a quick win.
- “Would love to feature [Product Name]—only takes 2 minutes to submit.”
- “You can list for free and get featured in front of an audience interested in launching tech.”
Emphasize low commitment while highlighting benefits like SEO, traffic, or visibility. If your platform excels at this, don’t be shy about linking to your FAQs or pricing to reduce friction further.
4. Sign Off Like a Human
Avoid turning your email into a brochure. Use a friendly tone and sign off like you’re talking to someone at a café—not making a pitch to an investor.
- “No pressure at all—just thought it could be a good fit.”
- “If it sounds useful, check us out here: [Link]. Happy to help however I can!”
Remember, this is relationship-building. Even if they don’t convert right away, you’re laying a foundation for future engagement or referrals.
Cold Email Script Example
Here’s a sample cold email structured with the above principles. This template works beautifully for directory owners using platforms like NurturingMail to reach startups right after their Product Hunt launch:
Subject: Big congrats on [Product Name] 🎉 Hi [First Name], Saw [Product Name] go live on Product Hunt today—huge congrats! Really liked your angle on [specific feature or unique value]. Launching is no small feat, so wanted to send a quick note. I run [Directory Name], a curated list of high-potential [niche] startups. We help new tools get discovered, picked up in newsletter roundups, and earn valuable early backlinks. Would love to feature [Product Name]—takes 2 minutes to submit (link). Totally free, and happy to highlight your PH launch too. No pressure at all—just thought it could help with visibility now while momentum is fresh. Best, [Your Name]
This format is short, sweet, and highly effective. Using automation tools like NurturingMail, you can personalize this email at scale and send outreach every 15–20 minutes to avoid spam triggers.
Personalization: The Secret Sauce
Personalization isn’t just a buzzword—it’s the tipping point between being ignored and opening a dialogue. Emails that use the founder’s name, product name, and contextual relevance significantly outperform generic mass emails.
Automated solutions like NurturingMail’s real-time Product Hunt tracking make this easy. As new products launch, emails are sent in a timely, considerate manner with custom copy.
Key Features That Make Cold Outreach Easy
If you’re manually trying to email startups one by one, your growth will hit a ceiling. Here’s why using automation tools makes a difference:
| Feature | Manual Outreach | NurturingMail |
|---|---|---|
| PH Launch Tracking | Needs daily checking | Auto-detected in real time |
| Email Personalization | Manual copy-pasting | Auto-generated per launch |
| Spam Avoidance | Easy to trigger filters | Optimized interval sending |
| Time Investment | Several hours/week | Zero after initial setup |
You can browse more on how this works on NurturingMail’s feature page or understand cost-savings via their pricing page.
Internal Links: Boosting Platform Stickiness
Once you get a startup to submit to your directory, make the most of that engagement. Link their listing within relevant blog posts, newsletters, and category pages. This not only helps their SEO but strengthens your domain authority too. Sites like Uno Directory use this tactic successfully to keep visitors exploring related products and tools.
Other Resources to Learn From
Diving deeper into the ecosystem can also help. Platforms like praneetbrar.com discuss indie hacker marketing tactics, while this Ahrefs guide on outreach emails is excellent for understanding industry best practices.
Final Thoughts: Play the Long Game
Cold emails aren’t magic spells, but composed correctly, they open doors. With tools like NurturingMail, it becomes effortless to maintain daily outreach at scale without ever sounding robotic or impersonal.
From the subject line to your closing note, every line matters when emailing startup founders. Talk like a human, show timely relevance, and include a clear but soft CTA. When done right, not only will you increase submissions and backlinks but also forge lasting relationships with the most innovative creators of tomorrow.
To get started with powerful, automated outreach, check the plans and frequently asked questions and see how you can scale your startup directory the smart way.